QB · NYG · age 23.8
J.J. McCarthy
J.J. McCarthy: dynasty value far higher than 30 days ago; QB30 in Superflex
Dynasty verdict: Rising and already priced above Our Value — the market is ahead of our model. (30 days: far higher; market clearly above Our Value.)
- Superflex value
- 1,813QB30 · #116 overall (12-team PPR)
- 1QB value
- 954QB29 · #192 overall (12-team PPR)
- Age
- 23.8QB · NYG · age 23.8
- Team
- NYGQB
How his value moved (Superflex)
- 7 days
- ▼ A bit lowermarket value
- 30 days
- ▲ Far highermarket value
- 1 year
- ▼ Far lowermarket value
Dynasty value over time
History: Our Value history: weekly before 2026-09-29, daily from then. Before the daily values began the line follows the weekly blend, rescaled to meet the daily line where they join.
Market vs Our Value
- Superflex
- 1,813market · Our Value 1,545
- 1QB
- 954market · Our Value 837
The market prices him clearly above Our Value. Market = the trade market's value (12-team PPR).
What J.J. McCarthy has actually traded for
Based on 99 real trades in the last 90 days where he was the main piece, J.J. McCarthy fetched clearly less than his listed value.
In today's points, that is about 1,347 against a listed value of 1,813. Real trades are running a bit below Our Value.
- Based on 67 real trades in the last 30 days where he was the main piece, J.J. McCarthy fetched clearly less than his listed value.
Three real packages
- 2027 3rd · Sep 2026
- Keon Coleman (WR) · Oct 2026
- 2027 3rd + 2028 2nd · Oct 2026
Based on 99 real trades in 97 public Sleeper dynasty leagues. Only trades where he was the main piece count, each valued on the day it happened. Listed value now: 1,813 · Our Value 1,545. Trades that look lopsided or collusive are left out, and trades with an asset we cannot price are not counted. See what managers are trading this week.
See every real trade for J.J. McCarthy →
Expectation vs reality (2024 rookie class)
Drafted as QB4 at 1.08; now worth about a mid 2nd (the 2.07 slot): far under expectation.
Best season: QB30 (PPR), 13.7 PPG vs 15.5 expected at his slot. Window still open: no top-12 QB season yet.
Slot expectation = the market value of his rookie-draft slot (Superflex) times the realized-return calibration behind the Draft ROI grade. Values from our stored Our Value history. See the 2024 class and every class.
QBs valued near J.J. McCarthy
- Ty Simpson — QB27 · LAR · 1,993
- Malik Willis — QB28 · MIA · 1,886
- Carson Beck — QB29 · ARI · 1,836
- Kyler Murray — QB31 · MIN · 1,768
- Daniel Jones — QB32 · IND · 1,734
- Shedeur Sanders — QB33 · CLE · 1,637